unforum
a.r.g.b.b
Calendar
FAQ
Search
Memberlist
Usergroups
Register
Log in
Welcome!
New users, PLEASE read
these forum guidelines
. New posters,
SEARCH
before posting and read
these rules
before posting your killer new campaign. New players may also wish to peruse the
ARG Player Tutorial
.
All users must abide by the
Terms of Service
.
This week sponsored by:
You
?
Why
do we need
your help
?
Announcements
The Project MU Archives
Now available in stunning full-color print edition.
Our Esteemed Contributors
The time now is Thu May 23, 2013 3:23 am
All times are UTC - 6
View posts in this forum since last visit
View unanswered posts in this forum
Calendar
Calendar
Wed 22 May 2013
Thu 23 May 2013
Fri 24 May 2013
Sat 25 May 2013
Sun 26 May 2013
Mon 27 May 2013
Tue 28 May 2013
Forum index
»
Diversions
»
TimeWasters
Puzzle Experiment #4
Post a reply
Username
Confirmation code
Subject
Subject description
Message icons
No icon
Message body
Emoticons
View more Emoticons
Font colour:
Default
Dark Red
Red
Orange
Brown
Yellow
Green
Olive
Cyan
Blue
Dark Blue
Indigo
Violet
White
Black
Font size:
Font size
Tiny
Small
Normal
Large
Huge
Close Tags
[quote="Agent Lex"]So you did. Silly me.[/quote]
Options
HTML is
ON
BBCode
is
ON
Smilies are
ON
Disable HTML in this post
Disable BBCode in this post
Disable Smilies in this post
Forum index
»
Diversions
»
TimeWasters
Topic review
Page 1 of 2
[27 Posts]
Goto page:
1,
2
Next
Author
Message
Tenchizard
Omega wrote:
Quick question for the community: Do you find that you enjoy a puzzle more if it is given to you or if you have to find it first? What about when you can't even find the puzzle?
Thanks, everyone, for all your criticism!
I liked the way the first clue was just subtle enough so that only interested people will follow trough (the link in the card). Then, when you get to the web page and see nothing at all, you get a bit disoriented. But if you're still interested, you click in one of the products and... there you go, you see all the owies and worms and such, and then you imagine there's a puzzle there, even if you don't know the rules.
Of course, if there had been a form to fill in the page, the need to do an order would be more clear.
Posted: Mon May 19, 2008 2:46 am
Rogi Ocnorb
I've been wondering if there wasn't a little more to that last one. Just haven't had time to look at it, much.
Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 6:35 pm
Omega
danteIL wrote:
So this was good in the sense that it was a puzzle that didn't necessarily look like a puzzle
Quick question for the community: Do you find that you enjoy a puzzle more if it is given to you or if you have to find it first? What about when you can't even find the puzzle?
Thanks, everyone, for all your criticism!
Posted: Fri May 16, 2008 3:59 pm
rowan
I think Lex hit on most of my feelings for this puzzle. Overall, I liked it. It seemed like it easily could have been part of a larger game. I'm even willing to write off the 'contrivedness' of the first bit as being part of some wacky universe that the game is set in (you could even remove the dollar amounts and have the cat tails, frog eyes, owies, etc as being the currency of this odd little site/game/universe - and maybe they offer some sort of recipe of the week). The whole thing feels rather whimsical, so I'm willing to be stretched further along and pretend a bit more - especially if this was something that occurred mid-game and I was already well acquainted with the way the universe worked.
The biggest thing I would change? Making the bottom text easier to read on the initial card. The url is really sorta blurry and would be a terrible marketing move for Cheap Gifts for Mom if no one could find their site.
Posted: Thu May 15, 2008 8:24 am
Agent Lex
That would probably be my fault. I started talking about solving the puzzle before posting how I *got* to the puzzle.
Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 3:17 pm
danteIL
I think this was clever (although I agree that the whole 'monster-mom' thing seems a bit random). In the context of a larger game, it might even work well because players would have to realize that they need to find the right 'recipe' in order to make further progress.
Outside the context of a game, however, it left me a bit mystified at first, especially when people started talking about 'balancing' owlies and such. So this was good in the sense that it was a puzzle that didn't necessarily look like a puzzle, but less good because there was no compelling reason to try to actually create a monster-mom gift or whatever.
I appreciate your variety though
Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 11:21 am
Omega
Re: Solution & Wrap-Up
SuperSlug wrote:
If you delete 1 Flower Basket that fixes the Cat Tail and Snake Tooth but still leaves you at -1 Owie.
Neat. I wrote the wrong values for the carnations! Was supposed to be -1 worm head and -1 owie. And yes, the number of flower baskets is only 1. Thanks for catching that, Slug.
So, strangely enough, the recipe worked out by accident!
I guess that's another lesson for this week:
Always double-check your numbers.
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 6:02 pm
Omega
Re: Solution & Wrap-Up
SuperSlug wrote:
Hmmm, with this order I come up +1 Cat Tail, +1 Snake Tooth, -1 Owie when compared to the MishMash recipe.
Strange. I'll double-check that... I may have written it down wrong!
Agent Lex wrote:
Out of curiosity, what would have happened if someone had sent an order that didn't match the recipe?
I would have emailed back with:
Quote:
Mr./Ms. <name>,
There appears to be an error regarding the order you recently placed through Cheap Gifts For Mom. Our records claim that you have requested a purchase of exactly 10,000 assorted cakes. Please verify your order by resubmitting your purchase request.
We apologize for any inconvenience caused on our behalf. During this hectic Mother's Day, our support staff is in constant motion responding to all the many orders we've received. We're working as fast as we can to ensure the quickest, cheapest Mother's Day deliveries with as little delay as possible.
Again, we apologize for any conflicts with your order. Please resubmit your order and our trained staff will process your request as soon as possible.
Thank you for shopping with Cheap Gifts For Mom!
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 5:39 pm
SuperSlug
Re: Solution & Wrap-Up
Omega wrote:
Concerning the first puzzle, the solution I had for a Monster Mom recipe was:
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
1 Calliope Flowers w/Vase
2 Flower Baskets
1 Carnations
1 Godiva Chocolates
2 Gift Baskets
2 Silver Necklaces
1 Assorted Cake
1 Gift Card Holder
2 Picture Frames
Hmmm, with this order I come up +1 Cat Tail, +1 Snake Tooth, -1 Owie when compared to the MishMash recipe.
If you delete 1 Flower Basket that fixes the Cat Tail and Snake Tooth but still leaves you at -1 Owie.
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 5:23 pm
Agent Lex
Re: Solution & Wrap-Up
Omega wrote:
But, I don't know where Lex lives, so...
I could tell you... just to torment you
Omega wrote:
Hints:
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
The gift voucher id was "1806-1802 BC," which was the brief period in which Sobeknefru ruled as Pharaoh.
Egypt was mentioned in the website's news section.
The sales rep's name was Anah Amenemhat Bithiah. Bithiah (Bitya in Hebrew) refers to the daughter of a Pharaoh. Pharaoh Amenemhat III is believed to be the father of Sobeknefru. Thus, the Bithiah of Amenemhat would be Sobeknefru. Also, Anah is a Hebrew girl's name meaning "answer."
I didn't even read that section of the site, actually! And the general Egyptian-ness of the name, along with the dates, are what gave it away. But that's a good few redundant hints there
General comments:
This felt more like an actual ARG than a standalone puzzle or a trail. Still, the puzzles did seem contrived (why make the monster mom? where did the "properties" of each item come from?)
Other than being a bit contrived, I actually liked the first puzzle. A couple of false assumptions to make (both Rogi and I assumed we could only use a maximum of 1 of each item, at first) and fairly hard, but solvable in more than one way.
As I said, the multiple hints for the second puzzle were a nice touch.
Out of curiosity, what would have happened if someone had sent an order that didn't match the recipe?
I'll let the professional critics take the floor now
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 4:40 pm
Omega
Solution & Wrap-Up
Cheap Gifts For Mom wrote:
Mr. Lex,
Thank you for completing the authorization process. Your order has been confirmed and shipped. You may expect a delivery within the next 3-5 business days.
At this point, a package would be sent out to Lex. The order would be mixed up, and Lex would receive the wrong items, which would provide clues for the next step of the ARG. But, I don't know where Lex lives, so... That's my thinking, anyway.
The final password was:
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
Sobeknefru.
Hints:
The gift voucher id was "1806-1802 BC," which was the brief period in which Sobeknefru ruled as Pharaoh.
Egypt was mentioned in the website's news section.
The sales rep's name was Anah Amenemhat Bithiah. Bithiah (Bitya in Hebrew) refers to the daughter of a Pharaoh. Pharaoh Amenemhat III is believed to be the father of Sobeknefru. Thus, the Bithiah of Amenemhat would be Sobeknefru. Also, Anah is a Hebrew girl's name meaning "answer."
That's it! That's all I had prepared, anyway. For this experiment, I wanted to test my hand at subtle puzzles, playing with the TINAG feeling. This was also the first experiment to incorporate outside sources (website & email). Any feedback regarding those elements would be greatly appreciated!
Concerning the first puzzle, the solution I had for a Monster Mom recipe was:
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
1 Calliope Flowers w/Vase
2 Flower Baskets
1 Carnations
1 Godiva Chocolates
2 Gift Baskets
2 Silver Necklaces
1 Assorted Cake
1 Gift Card Holder
2 Picture Frames
However, the combination that SuperSlug gave also works, and was a much simpler recipe. I wasn't sure if there was another combination, but Slug found one. Good job! Again, any criticism on this puzzle is welcomed.
Solve Time:
2 days, 16 minutes
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 4:29 pm
Agent Lex
Thanks, now I don't have to double post
Looks like I was correct.
Quote:
Mr. Lex,
Thank you for completing the authorization process. Your order has been confirmed and shipped. You may expect a delivery within the next 3-5 business days.
We hope you enjoyed shopping with us!
Anah Amenemhat Bithiah
Customer Support / Sales Rep
Cheap Gifts For Mom
http://cheapgiftsformom.exofire.net
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 4:18 pm
Tenchizard
So, this was a puzzle after all!
keep us updated, please!
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 4:01 pm
Agent Lex
Quote:
Mr. Lex,
Welcome back to Cheap Gifts For Mom! Our records show that you have shopped with us before. We hope you were satisfied with your purchase!
Below is a list of items you recently requested from our store. Please confirm the amount:
Spoiler (Rollover to View):
$20.00 - Gift Basket x 2
$10.00 - Silver Necklace x 2
$1.00 - Gift Card Holder x 1
$2.00 - Picture Frame x 1
$7.00 - Calliope Flowers w/Vase x 1
$3.00 - Flower Basket x 1
$6.00 - Godiva Chocolates x 1
--------------------
Total: $49.00
--------------------
Because you have shopped with us before, the credit card we have on record for your account will be automatically charged, and the requested items will be shipped directly to your address!
WANT TO SAVE MORE?
Mr. Lex, our records show that you have 1 unclaimed gift receipt valued at $25.00, redeemable on any purchase of more than $40.00. Your gift receipt id is: 1806-1802:BC. Would you like to redeem your gift receipt with this purchase?
IMPORTANT!
Before your order can be placed, you must validate the purchase using your account password. Please respond to this email with your password to complete the authorization process.
HOW WAS YOUR EXPERIENCE?
Here at Cheap Gifts For Mom, we value our customer's feedback and support. If you've experienced any troubles in placing an order or receiving purchased items, let us know! Your satisfaction is our satisfaction!
Thank you for shopping with Cheap Gifts For Mom!
Anah Amenemhat Bithiah
Customer Support / Sales Rep
Cheap Gifts For Mom
http://cheapgiftsformom.exofire.net
I'm guessing we're to guess the password based on the dates 1806-1802 BC...
ETA: Googling for 1802 BC comes up with this thread as the 5th result. Haha!
ETA 2:
Reigned 1806-1802 BC
. I'd say we have a match. I'm-a try sending that as the password, since it matches so well. Also, the guy's name seems to be Egyptian, which gives another hint to this.
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 2:46 am
SuperSlug
Agent Lex wrote:
Received reply, will post once I get to work and can c/p (I'm using the phone right now).
Yay! Thank you, Lex!
Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 2:12 am
Page 1 of 2
[27 Posts]
Goto page:
1,
2
Next
Back to top
Like this site and want to support it?
Powered by
phpBB
© 2001, 2005 phpBB Group